NGO Monitor Analysis (Vol. 2 No. 12) 15 August 2004
NIF - Some Improvements, but Funding of Anti-Israel NGOs Continues
Click here for
printer friendly version
Founded in 1979, the New Israel Fund claims to fight for civil
and human rights, to promote religious tolerance and pluralism,
and to close the social and economic gaps in Israeli society. NIF
has granted over $120 million to more than 700 organizations in
Israel. In 2003, the Ford Foundation announced a $20 million peace
and social justice fund in partnership with NIF. However, as previous
Monitor analyses have noted, some of NIF's funding goes to highly
politicized NGOs that are active in the anti-Israel demonization
campaign at the UN and elsewhere. These political NGOs systematically
exploit the rhetoric of civil society, democracy and human rights
to isolate and delegitimate Israel and Israeli policies.
In reviewing NIF policy since the previous report (October 2003), there is little evidence of significant change. According to its website, NIF continues provides funding for Adalah, I'lam, Mossawa, Hamoked, and the Arab Association for Human Rights - all of which have a clear record of anti-Israeli propaganda.
defines itself an "independent human rights organization…and …
non-partisan legal center …to protect human rights in general,
and the rights of the Arab minority (in Israel) in particular",
this NGO is very active in international
political advocacy. For example, in a July 22, 2004 press
claimed that Israeli actions have "been executed on an extensive
scale, and is therefore considered a war crime under international
law," while failing to mention the context behind Israeli counter-terror
operations. The organization was also prominent in drafting
many of the accusations of Israeli 'apartheid' and 'institutional
racism' for the NGO Declaration that was issued in parallel to
the World Conference against Racism in Durban in September 2001.
Nevertheless, NIF continues to provide funding for this blatantly
is another highly visible political NGO funded by the NIF, and
a leader of the demonization campaign against Israel. I'lam is
a major source of media distortions of the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict through its criticism of the professionalism of Israeli
journalism and the promotion of one-sided Palestinian narratives.
The dominance of I'lam's political objectives and use of standard
Palestinian rhetoric are demonstrated in its December 2000 report
"The Israeli Media
and the Intifada" which states: "the war is taking place on
the territories of the party, who is completely under siege and
possesses mere rocks and rifles, whereas, the other party possesses
the largest military arsenal in the Middle East." Ironically,
I'lam condemns the Israeli media for taking what I'lam sees as
a one-sided approach to reporting on the conflict.
also funded by NIF, was founded in 1997, "to promote equality
for Arab/Palestinians within the borders of Israel." Officially,
Mossawa claims to focus on changing "the social and political
status of Arab/Palestinians in Israel in an attempt to gain minority
recognition and rights, without sacrificing their national and
cultural rights as Palestinians." In reality, Mossawa's main focus
is political, and designed to delegitimize Israel on the basis
of blanket charges of "racism" and similar pejoratives, as highlighted
in a tendentious June
2004 report entitled "Racism in Israel." Similar to I' lam,
the Mossawa report criticized the media and legal system in Israel
claiming that "The legal system expands its use of consideration
and criticism of the freedom of speech, while it talked about
inciting for racism against the Arab citizens." The report also
condemns Israeli political leaders for "inciting and racist expressions
against the Arab citizens." Arab hostility towards Israel and
involvement in terror is ignored by this NIF-supported group.
Center for the Defense of the Individual also has a highly politicized
anti-Israel agenda, including indifference to Israeli civil and
human rights, and empathy for Palestinian terrorists in its distorted
and unbalanced reports. NIF funding for this NGO continues.
Arab Association of Human Rights, with the aid of NIF funding,
produces a regular weekly review of the Arab press, often presenting
distorted and superficial perspective. As this activity clearly demonstrates, HRA's goal is not to implement universal human rights principles, but rather to further its own political agenda.
However, based on the information on NIF's website, in the past
year, this organization has stopped direct assistance for some
Israeli Arab NGOs that were active in the Durban conference and
other demonization activities. For example, Ittijah
which also backed the campaign of the Palestinian
Non-Governmental Organizations Network (PNGO) against USAID's
anti-terrorism clause is no longer listed as a recipient of NIF funding.
Another politicized NGO that no longer appears on the NIF grant
list is Physicians
for Human Rights - Israel (PHR-I) an organization that has
consistently abused human rights in pursuit of its political agenda.
PHR-I's website continues to list NIF as a funding source, apparently
indicating an arrangement whereby NIF serves as a conduit for
In summary, while it appears that NIF has responded to some of the NGOs who have misused funding to pursue an anti-Israel agenda by removing their donations, NIF still continues to fund many others. A full-scale professional review of the New Israel Fund's support for political NGOs is long overdue.