To read this article, click here.
Asked about an executive summary report from the Jerusalem-based NGO Monitor outlining Spanish governmental funds for anti-Israeli Spanish and Middle Eastern NGOs, de Benito said, “The last thing we would do would be to finance NGOs against Israel or other countries.”
NGO Monitor noted in its report that “between 2009 and 2011, approximately 15 million euros in Spanish public funds (central government and regions) have been transferred to political advocacy NGOs active in promoting this agenda through the different funding frameworks (5 million euros to Israeli and Palestinian NGOs, and 10 million euros to Spanish NGOs). The federal government funding is generally provided through the aid agency AECID.”
NGO Monitor accused Applied Research Institute Jerusalem, which received 176,637 euros (2011) in Spanish funds, of promoting boycott activity against Israel and demonization of the Jewish state, including membership in the Palestinian Grassroots Anti- Apartheid Wall Campaign and support for the global anti- Israel boycott movement
NGO Monitor listed Breaking the Silence: the Israeli Committee Against House Demolitions; and the Popular Struggle Coordination Committee as NGOs that bash Israel while being awarded Spanish funds.
In response to de Benito’s statement, Prof. Gerald Steinberg, the head of NGO Monitor, told the Post on Wednesday, “The statement by the deputy foreign minister is a clear and welcome change in Spanish government policy. Unfortunately, previous governments have fueled the conflict by providing millions of euros taxpayer funds to some of the most destructive NGOs, under the facade of promoting peace and human rights. By ending this funding, the Spanish taxpayer will also benefit, and the European Union and the member states, which waste over 100 million euros annually on destructive NGOs, will have an important example to follow.”
Nader Hrimat, the deputy director-general of Applied Research Institute Jerusalem, said NGO Monitor is “not in a legal position to make a judgment about any organization, and our site is open for all people. We are not a political organization. We talk about natural resources and environmental rights.”
Asked about language used to demonize Israel, including the phrase “ethnic cleansing,” he said, “We have case studies about the environment. I do not know about this issue.”
Breaking the Silence listed on its website “the Spanish Agency for International Cooperation” as a funder. A Post email to Breaking the Silence was not immediately answered.
NGO Monitor wrote in its report that the Israeli Committee Against House Demolitions received 181,508 euros (2009–2010) from Spain and “promotes the demonization of Israel, supports boycotts and divestment campaigns, and leads the ‘Gaza boat’ publicity missions. Founder Jeff Halper advocates for a ‘one-state solution’ that would eliminate Jewish self-determination rights.”
Halper told the Post by telephone on Thursday that Spain provided “$50,000 to $60,000 in 2012,” and the “intervention of Spain is appropriate.”
“ICAHD support the BDS [boycott, divestment and sanctions] campaign against Israel until the Occupation ends,” he wrote to the Post by email.
Halper rejected idea that the committee demonizes or delegitimizes Israel. “We see it [BDS] as holding Israel accountable for its policies just like any other state.”
He added, “I was on the first boat of the Free Gaza Movement to actually enter Gaza, in August 2008,” and noted that “ICAHD has moved towards a one-state solution.”
Steinberg told the Post, “Halper acknowledges that the funding that ICAHD receives from foreign governments, including Spain, is used to promote his own private opinions, in contrast to the policies of the democratically elected government of Israel. This is clearly an abuse of taxpayer funds and violates the norms of relations between sovereign democracies.
How would Spain and other European countries react to foreign state funding for fringe separatists?” The Popular Struggle Coordination Committee wrote the Post that it “is receiving funding from the Spanish government for human rights defenders and legal aid. The Spanish government has publicly provided information regarding their funding criteria as well as the organizations they support on their website.”