Belgian NGOs “Mitigate Pro-Israel Voices” with Government Support
According to Belgian law, the government must approve a Joint Strategic Framework (JSF) in order to distribute foreign development assistance in different parts of the world. The JSF documents, formulated jointly by Belgian NGOs (non-governmental organizations) that implement aid projects in a given region, outline the NGOs’ common strategy for delivering aid. They are then submitted for government approval.
The 2017-2021 JSF for Belgian aid to Palestinians “was coordinated by Broederlijk Delen in close collaboration with the JSF Palestine working group (with Oxfam Solidarity, M3M, SolSoc and APEFE),” and was approved in 2016 by the Belgian Minister of Development Cooperation.
- Broederlijk Delen is the semi-official Catholic aid agency in Belgium, and receives significant government funds.
- Oxfam Solidarity (OxfamSol), M3M (now known as Viva Salud), and Solidarité Socialiste (SolSoc) are politicized anti-Israeli NGOs. Each has partnered with Palestinian NGOs linked to a EU-designated terrorist group, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP). (See Belgium’s Support of PFLP Linked NGOs.)
“Mitigating the influence of pro-Israel voices”
This JSF commits its signatories to promoting a variety of anti-Israel campaigns, through advocacy and lobbying in Belgium and the EU:
- Joint Strategic Goal number 3, “Good Governance, Civil Society and Human Rights,” calls for strengthening “local CSOs [civil society organizations] to increase their advocacy efforts towards the European institutions and member states, promoting respect for international law and mitigating the influence of pro-Israel voices” (emphasis added). Broederlijk Delen, Viva Salud, and OxfamSol will implement projects aimed at achieving this goal.
- The JSF also includes as a commitment to “improve common advocacy work on the Belgian and European level through the Middle East Platform, common advocacy campaigns such as Made in Illegality, actions around 50 years of occupation (2017) and organizing advocacy tours to Palestine and Israel for policy makers” (emphasis added).
- The “Made in Illegality” campaign calls upon Belgium, France, and the EU to end their economic relations with Israeli “settlements” – including demanding that companies from these countries end their participation in constructing the Jerusalem light rail system.
- The campaign’s demands include banning imports of all “settlement products,” discouraging Belgian companies “from investing in settlements,” and preparing information for travelers “to ensure that they avoid supporting companies and tourist sites that are located in the settlements.” This would presumably also include Jewish and Christian holy sites in Jerusalem, as well as the West Bank.
NGO Monitor Attacked in the Belgian Federal Parliament
One manifestation of JSF-mandated efforts to “mitigate[ing] the influence of pro-Israel voices” occurred in the Belgian Parliament on January 22, 2020. During a discussion of “sanctions against the colonization policy of Israel,” representatives of 11.11.11 and CNCD-11.11.11 – two Belgian NGO umbrella networks – presented a highly politicized publication entitled “Occupation and Shrinking Space,” which makes numerous false accusations against NGO Monitor. Broederlijk Delen, OxfamSol, and Viva Salud are all members of 11.11.11; OxfamSol and Viva Salud are members of CNCD-11.11.11.
- The 40-page report refers pejoratively to NGO Monitor research 49 times. It includes results from what they claim to be a survey conducted by 11.11.11 among Palestinian and Israeli NGOs, which identified NGO Monitor as one of “the most threatening actors” and “threatening their space to operate” (page 9, emphasis added).
- In addition, in this advocacy publication, the Belgian NGO networks recommend “EU institutions in Brussels, the EU Delegation in Tel Aviv, the EU Representation in Jerusalem and EU member states’ delegations in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem should review their relationships and engagement” with “groups such as NGO Monitor, as well as developing common EU messages towards such actors” (emphasis added).
11.11.11 and CNCD-11.11.11 both enjoy generous governmental funding.
- In 2018, 11.11.11 reported €9.1 million in government funding (out of €15.7 million in total revenue). €5.8 million of this was from the Belgium Directorate-General for Development Cooperation (DGD) and €551,337 from the EU.
- In 2018, CNCD-11.11.11 reported €2.7 million in governmental funding (out of €5.4 million in total revenue). €2.2 million was from the DGD, €342,808 from Fédération Wallonie-Bruxelles, €74,362 from the EU, and €22,500 from Wallonie-Bruxelles International (WBI).
Cooperation with the Palestinian Authority based on the JSF
Wallonie-Bruxelles International (WBI), “the agency responsible for the international relations of Wallonia and Brussels,” is funding “Justice for Palestinian Children in Conflict with the Law” (2019-2023; amount unknown). It appears that this funding is part of the implementation of the five-year international cooperation program (2019-2023) between WBI and the Palestinian Authority (PA) that focuses on child rights.
This project is being implemented by Defense for Children International-Belgium (DCI-Belgium) in partnership with Defense for Children International-Palestine (DCI-P).
Numerous individuals with alleged ties to the PFLP have been employed and appointed as board members at DCI-P. (Details at “Defense for Children International – Palestine’s Ties to the PFLP Terror Group.”) On June 26, 2018, UK Lawyers for Israel (UKLFI) announced that after being presented with evidence of the close ties between DCI-P and the PFLP to Citibank and Arab Bank PLC, “these banks no longer provide banking services to the terror linked NGO.” As a result, DCI-P no longer directs its supporters to make donations through these institutions. Global Giving, a US-based crowdfunding resource, also removed DCI-P from its website.
In February 2020, Belgium, which held the rotating presidency of the UN Security Council at the time, reversed its invitation of a DCI-P official to brief the Council. This follows a public information campaign highlighting the terror links of DCI-P and diplomatic protests by the Israeli government. (See “Belgium Reverses Invitation of DCI-P Official for UN Security Council Briefing – Background on Speaker and DCI-P’s PFLP Ties.
The document signed between WBI and the PA (May 2019) makes direct reference to the JSF, stating that “we align also on the 3rd Joint Strategic Goal of the Joint Strategic Framework (JSF),” and to the objective of strengthening “local CSOs [civil society organizations] to increase their advocacy efforts towards the European institutions and member states, promoting respect for international law and mitigating the influence of pro-Israel voices.”